Chicago’s bid for the 2016 Olympics still leaves some doubts over how the Games will be managed and financed, according to a report released today.
The International Olympic Committee issued a detailed evaluation report on each of the city candidates vying for the 2016 Olympics, which are Madrid, Spain, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Tokyo, Japan and Chicago.
Rio de Janeiro has been called the "emotional favorite" to win the bid, because an Olympic Games has never been held in South America, and the report emphasizes the cohesion between the city’s government, the national government, and the bid committee.
The report says that Chicago’s bid aspires to create a “spectacular experience” that would showcase the city’s acres public gardens, parks and lakeshore. However, it also cautions that the proposed relationship between City Hall and the Organizational Committee of the Olympic Games leaves “some doubt as to the ultimate responsibility for delivery of the Games.” Of particular concern to the report is how the city’s organizing committees, local government, and federal government will share responsibilities for implementing proposed environmental and mass-transit initiatives.
The report also details the projected costs for holding the games, including the budget for venue operations ($1.06 billion), Games employees ($509 million) and transportation ($226 million). The evaluation also tucks a wary prognosis on Chicago’s financing plans into its additional comments section: “the budget is ambitious but achievable.” The city-commissioned report on the Olympic bid by the Civic Federation, released last week, has deemed the Olympics budget “adequate.”
Another concern of the report is that Chicago had not agreed to fully guarantee the Olympic Games for the IOC in April when the report was commissioned. The full financial guarantee, a staple of all past host city agreements with the IOC, has been the source of much tension between City Hall and the community in recent months because of fears that such a guarantee will burden taxpayers.
On a more positive note, the evaluation offers some praise for the temporary venue construction projects, such as the Olympic Stadium and Aquatic Center, which would be deconstructed after the Games into smaller, public venues to be used by the Washington Park community. This concept, according to the report, supports previous recommendations to the IOC that the Olympics host city should “build a new venue only if there is a legacy need.” In Chicago’s case, the bid committee determined that the city did not need an 80,000-seat stadium or an Aquatic Center with four Olympic-sized pools, but would benefit from the venues if the stadium could be shrunken after games, and the pools moved separately to other parts of the city.
These plans, the report concludes, would to some extent reduce the environmental impact of hosting the Games.
The report also cites the White House’s new “Olympic Office” and the “Memorandum of Understanding,” an agreement between the bid committee and community members, as positive examples of public support for the bid. However, it also said that a public opinion poll commissioned by the IOC shows Chicago has the second-lowest popular support for its bid among the four candidate cities, with local support at 67% and national support at 61%.
Click here to view the complete report.
Showing posts with label Aquatic Center. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Aquatic Center. Show all posts
Wednesday, September 2, 2009
Thursday, August 6, 2009
As bid for the 2016 Olympics heats up, Chicagoans find a natural refuge in Washington Park
One of Michael LaBarbera’s favorite weekend past-times is wandering through Washington Park, snapping photographs of the herons and dragonflies that surround its lagoons. He appreciates the park’s peacefulness, and the opportunity to get a great shot of a dragonfly hovering over the water, or a heron fishing.
But LaBarbera, a Hyde Park resident, knows that his neighborhood haunt will be transformed over the next decade if Chicago wins its bid for the 2016 Olympics. Washington Park contains one of the cities largest arboretums and is host to many species of birds and insects that stand to be effected should the city move forward with plans to put the Olympic Stadium and aquatic center in the Park’s north end.
“I am very much in favor of the Olympics,” LaBarbera said. But he is also worried about how the construction projects and influx of hundreds of people will impact the park’s nature areas and fauna.
“I don’t know how to reconcile those two things,” he added.
LaBarbera, a biology professor at the nearby University of Chicago, sometimes brings students from his class on invertebrate zoology to the Park to study water from the lagoons. The lagoons are host to several varieties of native-Midwestern birds, including Caspian terns, great blue herons and white-crowned herons.

An autumn meadowhaw perches on a twig in Washington Park (Photo by Michael LaBarbera)
“The lagoons are artificial, and those are surrounded by some areas that [the Chicago Park Service] planted with native plants,” he said. “They’re not unique plants, but given that we’ve plowed onto the prairie, they’re not exactly common either these days.” Though Washington Park was designed in 1871 to host the Columbian Exhibition and is not a natural park, “it’s the closest to a wild piece of land we’ve got in Hyde Park.”
Preservationists worry that Washington Park, one of urban planner Fredrick Law Olmsted’s most significant design projects after New York City’s Central Park, will have its National Landmark status revoked if Olympic proposals do not conform to the Park’s historic design plans. Some preservationist organizations and members of local sports teams have also probed Chicago 2016 officials in recent community forums on how many years the park may be closed to traffic during construction.
According to LaBarbera, the wildlife should not be affected by Olympics construction much more than it currently is during the summer months, when the park plays host to several festivals and a Fourth of July celebration.
“The whole park is completely packed with people, and more smell of barbecue lighter than you can imagine,” he said. “And you do see an impact on the wildlife. The birds go away for a couple of days. But then they come back.”
"It's very hard to construct a venue without devastating the area around it, and if you later disassemble the venues then there’s nothing but field around you," according to architect Martin Felsen, who spoke at an open meeting about the legacy of the Burnham Plan on Tuesday.
Felsen, co-founder of the urban design firm UrbanLab and professor at the Illinois Institute of Technology, has been working with the Chicago 2016 committee on creating ecologically-forward plans. "We've looked at how communities can use the parks more, since [parklands] are not in such great condition some times, and then asked how people can engage open space more." To him, the Olympics could be an opportunity to promote physical health and community spirit, while exploring "green" urban planning initiatives.
Madiem Kawa echoes LaBarbera’s ambivalence. Kawa is a resident of Washington Park, the neighborhood on the park’s western border, and volunteers as the park’s nature area stewardess, organizing community clean-up events and tending to the park’s butterfly and dragonfly habitats. “I’m not opposed to the Olympics,"she says, but Kawa still has reservations.
“I don’t know what kinds of construction [Chicago 2016] will ultimately have in the Park, but I am concerned. If our tree population is taken away, for example, that would impact the number of bird habitats we have,” she said.
The Washington Park Arboretum, which Kawa describes as a ‘living tree museum,’ contains Lindens, Hickories and Bur Oaks, some of which have been alive since before the 1893 Columbian Exhibition. The arboretum is located in the park’s northwest end, close to the proposed Olympic Aquatic Center.
Like LaBarbera, Kawa can also list the species of birds she has seen in the park with ease: ducks, cardinals, finches, warblers, and one great white egret.
Kawa helps organize free bird-watching tours of the park and classes on plant-identification. “How can we educate the public and the Olympic committee to make sure [the nature areas] are not effected? That’s what I’m concerned about.”
Chicago 2016 has not responded to interview requests.

A green heron grabs lunch in Washington Park (Photo by Michael LaBarbera)
“If Chicago 2016 controls access to the park, I think they could actually preserve that wild area quite well,” LaBarbera said of the arboretum. “If they allow people to roam, it won’t be protected. But if they’re smart, they could actually take advantage of the peace and the tranquility of that area.”
But LaBarbera, a Hyde Park resident, knows that his neighborhood haunt will be transformed over the next decade if Chicago wins its bid for the 2016 Olympics. Washington Park contains one of the cities largest arboretums and is host to many species of birds and insects that stand to be effected should the city move forward with plans to put the Olympic Stadium and aquatic center in the Park’s north end.
“I am very much in favor of the Olympics,” LaBarbera said. But he is also worried about how the construction projects and influx of hundreds of people will impact the park’s nature areas and fauna.
“I don’t know how to reconcile those two things,” he added.
LaBarbera, a biology professor at the nearby University of Chicago, sometimes brings students from his class on invertebrate zoology to the Park to study water from the lagoons. The lagoons are host to several varieties of native-Midwestern birds, including Caspian terns, great blue herons and white-crowned herons.

An autumn meadowhaw perches on a twig in Washington Park (Photo by Michael LaBarbera)
“The lagoons are artificial, and those are surrounded by some areas that [the Chicago Park Service] planted with native plants,” he said. “They’re not unique plants, but given that we’ve plowed onto the prairie, they’re not exactly common either these days.” Though Washington Park was designed in 1871 to host the Columbian Exhibition and is not a natural park, “it’s the closest to a wild piece of land we’ve got in Hyde Park.”
Preservationists worry that Washington Park, one of urban planner Fredrick Law Olmsted’s most significant design projects after New York City’s Central Park, will have its National Landmark status revoked if Olympic proposals do not conform to the Park’s historic design plans. Some preservationist organizations and members of local sports teams have also probed Chicago 2016 officials in recent community forums on how many years the park may be closed to traffic during construction.
According to LaBarbera, the wildlife should not be affected by Olympics construction much more than it currently is during the summer months, when the park plays host to several festivals and a Fourth of July celebration.
“The whole park is completely packed with people, and more smell of barbecue lighter than you can imagine,” he said. “And you do see an impact on the wildlife. The birds go away for a couple of days. But then they come back.”
"It's very hard to construct a venue without devastating the area around it, and if you later disassemble the venues then there’s nothing but field around you," according to architect Martin Felsen, who spoke at an open meeting about the legacy of the Burnham Plan on Tuesday.
Felsen, co-founder of the urban design firm UrbanLab and professor at the Illinois Institute of Technology, has been working with the Chicago 2016 committee on creating ecologically-forward plans. "We've looked at how communities can use the parks more, since [parklands] are not in such great condition some times, and then asked how people can engage open space more." To him, the Olympics could be an opportunity to promote physical health and community spirit, while exploring "green" urban planning initiatives.
Madiem Kawa echoes LaBarbera’s ambivalence. Kawa is a resident of Washington Park, the neighborhood on the park’s western border, and volunteers as the park’s nature area stewardess, organizing community clean-up events and tending to the park’s butterfly and dragonfly habitats. “I’m not opposed to the Olympics,"she says, but Kawa still has reservations.
“I don’t know what kinds of construction [Chicago 2016] will ultimately have in the Park, but I am concerned. If our tree population is taken away, for example, that would impact the number of bird habitats we have,” she said.
The Washington Park Arboretum, which Kawa describes as a ‘living tree museum,’ contains Lindens, Hickories and Bur Oaks, some of which have been alive since before the 1893 Columbian Exhibition. The arboretum is located in the park’s northwest end, close to the proposed Olympic Aquatic Center.
Like LaBarbera, Kawa can also list the species of birds she has seen in the park with ease: ducks, cardinals, finches, warblers, and one great white egret.
Kawa helps organize free bird-watching tours of the park and classes on plant-identification. “How can we educate the public and the Olympic committee to make sure [the nature areas] are not effected? That’s what I’m concerned about.”
Chicago 2016 has not responded to interview requests.

A green heron grabs lunch in Washington Park (Photo by Michael LaBarbera)
“If Chicago 2016 controls access to the park, I think they could actually preserve that wild area quite well,” LaBarbera said of the arboretum. “If they allow people to roam, it won’t be protected. But if they’re smart, they could actually take advantage of the peace and the tranquility of that area.”
Saturday, July 25, 2009
Turnout is low among Washington Park residents at latest Olympics planning meeting
Some Chicagoans are eager to help Chicago 2016 plan for the Olympic bid, but Washington Park has few representatives at community meetings
Close to 60 Chicagoans debated the merits of plans for Washington Park in Chicago’s 2016 Olympic bid Saturday morning at the third Washington Park Olympic Venue Legacy meeting.
Despite the high turnout from residents of Hyde Park, Kenwood and a few North Side communities, Cecilia Butler, president of the Washington Park Advisory Council, was concerned that most of the attendees were not from Washington Park proper—the neighborhood just west of the park that expects to see substantial re-developments should Chicago win the bid.
“As a community resident and an active member of my park, I am somewhat disturbed…We have a lot of people in this room talking about this park who don’t live here.” Butler said in her opening remarks to the group. “Think about that, how would you like it if some people came to your community and talked on your behalf? Make sure you are an active user of this park before you feel like making decisions about it.”
Butler said in an interview that she estimates Washington Park residents accounted for no more than one quarter to one third of the meeting’s members, who came to discuss plans for temporary and permanent changes to the park and recommend planning improvements to the Chicago 2016 committee.
“I’m not so concerned about the Olympics in the park. No. I’m concerned for that community west of the park that will be really affected; the people who use this park and drive through it… the people who live on Cottage Grove,” she said. “Where are they?”
But Arnold Randall, Chicago 2016’s director of neighborhood outreach, who led the meeting, held at the Washington Park Refectory, 55th and King Drive, insisted that every opinion counted—not just residents of Washington Park.
“I think it’s important to stress that a lot of the people who come to these meetings use the park every day,” he said. “[Chicago 2016] thinks it’s important to hear what everybody has to say about it …from a community perspective.”
Butler said that Chicago 2016 has so far addressed most of the issues identified by her Council, which issued a “26-Point Plan” for how it thinks the Games should be operated. But the WPAC is still waiting for the committee to clarify what will happen to the local cricket and soccer teams who play in the park, and how soon park roads would be closed to through traffic after construction begins. WPAC supports the bid, Butler said, but only if Chicago 2016 meets all of their demands, which include, “Building trade contracts and On-the-Job training programs for the African-American community,” and a stipulation that re-located local sports teams be able to have their user fees at other recreational sites eliminated or reduced.
During the meeting, Randall emphasized the importance of community support for Chicago 2016’s plans, which include building a collapsible stadium and an aquatic center with four Olympic-sized pools, but did not distinguish between attendees from inside and outside Washington Park. According to Randall, the purpose of the meeting’s presentation and break-out sessions was foremost to gain input from residents about what structures should ideally remain in the park after the Games, and where they should go.
The possibilities include relocating three of the four swimming pools to other park districts while leaving the fourth in Washington Park for public use and to complement the already-existing Dyett community pool, he said; Chicago 2016 is also considering leaving behind a down-sized version of the Olympic stadium with 25 to 35 hundred seats to be used for festivals and public gatherings.
Randall and spokespeople for the Chicago Park District distributed worksheets to the collection of nearly one-dozen breakout session groups, and asked them to describe how they envision the Aquatic Center and stadium's legacies in the Park after the Games. Chicago 2016 officials later collected and recorded the groups’ recommendations into a power-point presentation.
Jonathan Fine, executive director of Preservation Chicago, a North Side-based advocacy group, lead his breakout session group. “We reject the proposal to build an Olympic stadium in Washington Park, and recommend that Chicago 2016 find an alternative venue,” Fine read from his sheet. Other members of the group, all hailing from Hyde Park, North Kenwood or Bronzeville, debated whether or not that message was too strong.
But Kublai Toure, who sat at a neighboring table, was less conflicted. “As a black man who has lived in this community for over 50 years, I’m very concerned about my people being displaced,” he said. “There’s a lot of elderly people still in the community who have fixed incomes, and [the economic changes the Olympics might bring] create a problem for them. We have no confidence in this city government whatsoever.”
Toure, who lives just north of the park on Grand Boulevard and acts as executive director of the neighborhood advocacy group Amer-I-Can Illinois, said he did not come to the planning meeting expecting to sway Chicago 2016 in any direction. “I think it’s a done deal—I didn’t get anything out of the meeting. I just wanted to let them know that there’s a lot of people who feel like I do.”
Madiem Kawa, another Washington Park resident, speculated that poor advertising might be responsible for the low attendance of local community members. Despite subscribing to the email list-host of her district’s alderman, Willie Cochran, Kawa did not learn about the planning meeting until she attended an un-related community meeting in Jackson Park.
Kawa is the volunteer stewardess of Washington Park’s nature areas, and leads volunteer programs in the park for the Chicago Park District. “They hold this meeting on one of my [volunteer group’s] regular work days,” she said. “We can’t normally attend the meetings unless they change the date or time.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)