"Make no little plans. They have no magic to stir men's blood ... Make big plans; aim high in hope and work."  
—Daniel Burnham, Chicago architect. (1864-1912)
Showing posts with label IOC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IOC. Show all posts

Friday, October 2, 2009

Breaking News: Chicago Eliminated in First Round of IOC Voting

Chicago was eliminated in the first round of voting at the International Olympics Committee conference to select the host city for the 2016 Summer Games this morning at 10:30 local time. The IOC voted today in Copenhagen Denmark in 3 rounds; One city is eliminated in each round of voting. Chicago was the first to go, followed by Tokyo.

Throngs of Chicago 2016 supporters in Daley Plaza watched in silence, mouths held open, as Jacques Rogin, president of the IOC, announced the results and proceeded with voting to the second round. Tokyo was eliminated next.

Analysts projected a showdown between Chicago and Rio de Janeiro, the supposed favorite to win because a Games had never before been held in South America. Instead, Madrid and Rio de Janeiro will proceed to the final round. The decision is to be announced by 11:30 local time.

UPDATE: Rio de Janeiro, thought by many to be the favorite to win and Chicago's biggest competitor in the bid, won the right to host the 2016 Olympic Games.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Tomorrow...

As I type, government officials and Olympic bid committees from Chicago, Madrid, Tokyo and Rio de Janeiro, among them President Barack Obama, are readying their final presentations to the International Olympics Committee. The IOC will vote for and select a host for the 2016 Summer Games between 11:30 a.m. and noon Chicago-time. No matter what the final decision brings the city, I had a lot of fun reporting on the politics, social and economic issues surrounding the bid, and I am thrilled that you took the time to read my blog.

I will be covering breaking news tomorrow morning at a block-party hosted by Aldermen Cochran, Preckwinkle, and Dowell at 52nd and Payne Drive, across from the site of the proposed Olympic Stadium in Washington Park. I hope to see you there.


Foot traffic is sparse at 55th and Indiana on a Saturday afternoon; should Chicago win the bid, tourists will frequent the Green Line CTA stop adjacent to this block to visit Washington Park


In the mean time, here is the link to an excellently written Washington Post story about the city's bid.

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Olympics News Roundup: 9/29

President—and former Chicagoan—Barack Obama is flying to Copenhagen to meet the International Olympic Committee, in an about-face from his announcement last week that Michelle Obama will represent the White House for the Oct. 2 decision. Obama will be the first sitting U.S. president to attend an Olympics conference ...


... But Chicagoans oppposed to the bid aren't alone in asking "What sacrifices must we make to host the Games?" According to USA Today, Obama's announcement that he will fly to Copenhagen to campaign for Chicago met with a flurry of criticism from some Americans, who suggested Obama's time would be better spent making policy decisions about healthcare and Afghanistan ...


... And Chicago Tribune columnist Mary Schmich argues that Chicago's bid is really all about the city's need for love—and money.

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

IOC report: Chicago's bid is "ambitious"

Chicago’s bid for the 2016 Olympics still leaves some doubts over how the Games will be managed and financed, according to a report released today.

The International Olympic Committee issued a detailed evaluation report on each of the city candidates vying for the 2016 Olympics, which are Madrid, Spain, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Tokyo, Japan and Chicago.


Rio de Janeiro has been called the "emotional favorite" to win the bid, because an Olympic Games has never been held in South America, and the report emphasizes the cohesion between the city’s government, the national government, and the bid committee.

The report says that Chicago’s bid aspires to create a “spectacular experience” that would showcase the city’s acres public gardens, parks and lakeshore. However, it also cautions that the proposed relationship between City Hall and the Organizational Committee of the Olympic Games leaves “some doubt as to the ultimate responsibility for delivery of the Games.” Of particular concern to the report is how the city’s organizing committees, local government, and federal government will share responsibilities for implementing proposed environmental and mass-transit initiatives.

The report also details the projected costs for holding the games, including the budget for venue operations ($1.06 billion), Games employees ($509 million) and transportation ($226 million). The evaluation also tucks a wary prognosis on Chicago’s financing plans into its additional comments section: “the budget is ambitious but achievable.” The city-commissioned report on the Olympic bid by the Civic Federation, released last week, has deemed the Olympics budget “adequate.”

Another concern of the report is that Chicago had not agreed to fully guarantee the Olympic Games for the IOC in April when the report was commissioned. The full financial guarantee, a staple of all past host city agreements with the IOC, has been the source of much tension between City Hall and the community in recent months because of fears that such a guarantee will burden taxpayers.

On a more positive note, the evaluation offers some praise for the temporary venue construction projects, such as the Olympic Stadium and Aquatic Center, which would be deconstructed after the Games into smaller, public venues to be used by the Washington Park community. This concept, according to the report, supports previous recommendations to the IOC that the Olympics host city should “build a new venue only if there is a legacy need.” In Chicago’s case, the bid committee determined that the city did not need an 80,000-seat stadium or an Aquatic Center with four Olympic-sized pools, but would benefit from the venues if the stadium could be shrunken after games, and the pools moved separately to other parts of the city.

These plans, the report concludes, would to some extent reduce the environmental impact of hosting the Games.

The report also cites the White House’s new “Olympic Office” and the “Memorandum of Understanding,” an agreement between the bid committee and community members, as positive examples of public support for the bid. However, it also said that a public opinion poll commissioned by the IOC shows Chicago has the second-lowest popular support for its bid among the four candidate cities, with local support at 67% and national support at 61%.

Click here to view the complete report.

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

The anthropologist in the Olympic Stadium

When John MacAloon began his research on the Olympics, past scholarship amounted to little more than a box of files in a room. Since then, he has published articles on the origins of the Olympic Movement, advised the International Olympic Committee, and sat on several bid committees and organizing committees.

He discusses the ideology behind the Olympic Movement, eminent domain, and why you won’t be renting out your South Side apartment during the Games:



Rachel Cromidas: You’re a professor of anthropology at the University of Chicago. How did you join Chicago 2016, the city’s bid committee?

John MacAloon: It’s more that the committee joined me. I’ve been working as an Olympics researcher, activist and consultant for about over 30 years now, and when Chicago decided to bid for the Olympics I was one of the few people in town who knew anything about the process.

RC: When you began your research on the Olympics, there was very little existing scholarship on the subject of the Olympic Movement.

JM: When I started, the Olympic Movement was not centralized. My PhD dissertation was a biography of the founder of the Olympic Games, and the story of origins of the Olympic Movement. There had been no such document until I wrote one, other than strict sports history, like who won the 200 meters in 1912, which is not what I do. Many Americans don’t know that the ritual system of the Olympics is by many measures as important as the sports system, because that’s where the ideology of the Olympic Movement comes in.

I study the Olympics as something that ought to be impossible, according to the field of anthropology. [the study of cultural difference]. If cultural differences are so important, then how is it that 205 national cultures and literally uncountable subcultures manage to come together every four years to interact and engage and cooperatively compete? That’s an astonishing achievement, and precisely what the Olympics are designed to demonstrate.

But if you think the Olympics is just sports event, then who cares, what’s the big deal? We’ve got plenty of sports events. But its not that, its absolutely not just that.

RC: What distinguishes the Olympic Movement from the Olympic Games?

JM: The difference is really important to understand if you want to understand what Chicago’s bid is about. Olympic sport is not like other sport. First of all, it’s not like professional baseball. If I ask you to tell me what’s the ideology of professional baseball, or what’s the ideology of NCAA Final Four, or what’s the ideology of the World Cup, you would struggle to answer. But you can tell me something about the opening ceremony of the Olympics. For most Olympics, the opening ceremony is far more important than an individual sports event. That’s because Olympic sport is sport in the service of international education, intercultural understanding, peace, détente, youth development, social justice. We Americans don’t really understand that.

RC: What makes the opening ceremony so important?

JM: Basically, to be considered “a nation among nations” requires marching in the opening ceremony or being a part of the United Nations. And there are more territories, countries, that march in the opening ceremonies than members of the UN—and that is for certain peoples of the world absolutely critical. For example, Puerto Rico appears as nation among nations only in Olympic sport, and its autonomy becomes dependent on Olympic sport. The Games are not everything of course, but in part, because Puerto Rico would lose its independent Olympic team, a referendum on statehood cannot win there.

RC: Do you think local opposition to the Olympic bid has been centered on the idea that we don’t need more sports games in the city?

JM: Some of it obviously has been. But if you’ve never experienced [the Olympics] directly, if you think watching NBC is the Olympics, then you are sadly benighted.

In Germany, until fairly recently, Olympism was taught in every school as the most important social movement of the 20th century after socialism and feminism. That’s a statement that makes no sense to the majority of Americans. They’ve never heard of Olympism, and there’s no tradition even in higher education of teaching this.

There’s also the Cultural Olympiad, which is another ritual of holding the Games. It is a major, four-year festival of arts and culture and education, which I will be leading for Chicago if we get the Games. You don’t hear about this on NBC.

RC: What do you think makes Chicago a more equipped city than the other candidates [Madrid, Rio de Janeiro, and Tokyo] to host the Olympics?

I’m not just working on this bid because this is my city and my city needed me. This is a city made for the Olympics. It’s because of those parks and because of the Burnham Plan. It’s because we are the only city in the world in which the finest real estate is owned by the people. Our ability to put the [temporary and permanent] sports facilities in the parks, by the lake, means we don’t displace a single person; we won't use eminent domain to take somebody’s business or somebody’s neighborhood. And our Olympic Village goes on an empty space, [Michael Reese Hospital]. All of that makes us profoundly different than other bids.

RC: Eminent domain aside, I have heard community members voice concerns that rising rents will displace the poorer residents of Washington Park, Grand Boulevard, and other South Side neighborhoods surrounding the proposed locations of the Olympic Stadium and Aquatic Center.

JM: Research tells us that whatever is happening in terms of property values or gentrification in the venue neighborhoods will be virtually unchanged by anything having to do with the Olympics.

Those worries [about displacement] are driven by people’s fantasies, not there fears. People think, “Oh great, for 17 days there’s going to be a huge crowd on the South Side. I’ll rent my apartment!” These people don’t know anything. If anyone coming to Chicago for the Olympics is very rich and renting places, they’re not renting your Hyde Park student apartment. And the people who are coming to work here are construction workers who are not renting.

RC: Is it also a fantasy that the Olympics would revitalize these neighborhoods?

JM: Yes. If you think that other than what is already going on that there will be a ton of business development on the South Side because of the Olympics, you don’t know anything. Of course, there is a major revitalization project in the Olympic Village. There, you will have a major new neighborhood on the South Side that is committed to being 30 percent affordable housing.

RC: What about the speculation that the University of Chicago is buying property in Washington Park in hopes that property values will rise after the Olympics?

JM: The University buying property in Washington Park has been an issue for the past 30 years, and it will continue to be an issue for the next 30. There have been discussions with the University and [Chicago 2016] about repurposing some parking lots near the park, but the notion that University is now buying property because of the Olympics…? What planet are people on? The Olympics are not about economic capital.

RC: Does the University stand to benefit from the Olympics in other ways?

JM: Of course. Think about this: If Chicago gets the Olympics, how many people would ever wonder again if we were the University of Illinois at Chicago? How many North Siders and suburbanites that have never been to the south side will be looking here?


John MacAloon is an associate dean of social sciences at the University of Chicago, where he teaches in the College, and director of the Social Sciences Master of Arts Program. He sits on the Chicago 2016 Bid Committee. This interview has been edited for length.

Friday, August 21, 2009

Behind the bid: Ald. Manny Flores rethinks rallying-cry, “No free check!”

It’s no news that 1st Ward Alderman Manny Flores is unhappy about how city government is handling Chicago’s bid for the 2016 Olympics. But less clear is what he plans to do about it.

Last month, Flores introduced legislation to the City Council that would cap the city’s spending at $500 million—a figure the council arrived at earlier in the planning stages of the bid, but later gave up once the International Olympic Committee made it clear back in June that host cities must agree to give the Olympics a full financial guarantee.

That bill is still pending in committee (Spokespeople from Flores’s office say they are waiting to hear word from City Hall, but the projected date of the hearing is Sept. 8). But some pundits have wondered whether Flores was actually abandoning the bill after he presented a new plan to make sure Chicago 2016 gets “No free check,” in a recent e Op-ed in the Chicago Tribune.

In the piece, Flores outlines a five-point plan for greater transparency from the city and Chicago 2016—and doesn’t mention the $500 million cap. But, he explained to me last week, this doesn’t mean he’s backing off; he’s just rethinking how a spending cap could help, and hurt, the city.

“I would not characterize [the op-ed] as backing down,” he said. “The thing is, you can’t have your cake and eat it. We could impose the cap, but we’ve already been told [by the IOC] that it would not be possible for us to win the bid.”

Flores originally suggested a cap on using city funds for the Olympics to safeguard against surprises like the one Mayor Richard Daley gave city aldermen back in June, when he seemed to tell the IOC that Chicago would sign the host city’s agreement on Oct. 2 if selected, and thereby pledge to fully insure the Olympics.

The aldermen, Flores added, “were informed that $500 million was the most the city would have to commit… and that the city was not going to be pursuing that type of guarantee that the IOC had imposed on other cities. We were under the impression we would not commit tax dollars or open ourselves up to a blank check.”

Flores now thinks his spending cap legislation stands to be modified in committee, hopefully along the lines he laid out in his op-ed, which asks for an independent oversight committee, and public records of all Games’ related spending.

According to Flores, that five-pronged mandate for transparency is the only way to keep the bid officials honest while still making Chicago a viable contender for the Games. Does this mean $500 million cap is history?

Not exactly, he said. “If we have protective mechanisms in place, we should pursue the Games. But I’m telling the 2016 Committee, if you don’t want to be transparent, then you’re going to get capped at $500 million dollars. If that kills the Games, then that will be it.”

Monday, July 27, 2009

Could the Olympics see Chicago through the recession?

Mayor Daley and Chicago 2016 say the 2016 Olympics are just the stimulus Chicago needs to ride out the current economic recession, according to a story in today's New York Times:

"To hear Ms. [Lori] Healey and other bid leaders tell it, there is no downside. If the International Olympics Committee were to choose Chicago over Madrid, Rio de Janeiro and Tokyo on Oct. 2, advocates predict the Games would not only break even but would also make money (as have, they say, earlier Olympics in the United States), generate more than $22 billion in indirect economic impact on the city and create $1 billion in new tax revenue. Many of the sites needed for the events would not require construction because they already exist."


I've met Chicagoans who agree with Healey's statement, and others who hear Chicago 2016 officials speak and instinctively clutch their pocketbooks tighter.

George Tolley, prof. emeritus of economics at the University of Chicago, is one South Sider who is still hesitant to say that Chicago will not have to draw from tax dollars to finance the bid.

"I don’t know what [Daley] really has in mind...he might be able to line up enough commitments from the private sector, if they're willing to commit themselves in a legally binding way," he said. But Daley "still has quite a bit of time to figure it out."

Butler Adams, a resident of Woodlawn, just southeast of the proposed Olympic Stadium and Aquatic Center sites, has been optimistic of the bid from early on—and his support remains strong, despite the weakened economy.

"You’ve got to spend money to make money. Its like an investment. If you put enough heart and spirit into that stock, there’s a greater chance you’ll be a beneficiary," he said.

Adams would like to see the city prove naysayers—and the groundswell of opposition that has formed in response to Mayor Daley's promise that Chicago will cover all potential losses for the International Olympic Committee—wrong.

"Chicago held the 1933 World’s Fair during the Great Depression, and it was so successful it was held over to another year. That could happen again."


UPDATE: Chicago isn't the only city rethinking its Olympic dreams in the face of an economic downturn; according to BBC News, London may move some 2012 Olympics venues to stay within its approximately $10 billion budget

Monday, June 22, 2009

Olympics News Roundup 6/22

Members of No Games Chicago returned from Lausanne, Switzerland, where they flew last week to protest the city's bid to members of the International Olympic Committee ...

... While Hawaii celebrated the international air travel that the Chicago Olympics would bring to the state's capital ...

... And President Obama gives America the "it-factor" that might push the second city ahead of its competition.




Volunteers for Chicago 2016 pass out "Olympic Rings" wristbands in Federal Plaza (6/18)

Tuesday is Olympic Day, and Chicago 2016 is hosting a morning of speeches and athleticism in Washington Park. Check back here for updates.